Gressel joined Inter Miami in January 2024, reuniting with former coach Gerardo “Tata” Martino, who had managed him at Atlanta United from 2017 to 2018 — a stretch during which Gressel won the MLS Rookie of the Year award. In his first season in Miami, he was a regular contributor, making 40 appearances, scoring one goal, and providing 10 assists.

Inter Miami return to MLS play on Sunday at home, where they take on FC Dallas as Lionel Messi's side continue their quest to defend their Supporters' Shield title. The Herons enter the match in fifth place in the Eastern Conference but have two games in hand and could still jump up to second place with a win,

Inter Miami CF had their undefeated MLS season come to an end on Sunday, falling to FC Dallas 4–3 in a dramatic afternoon affair.